top of page

The Impact of Public Policy & Structural Barriers on Neighborhood & Environment

PART OF A BEHAVIORAL SCIENCE LENS ON SOCIAL DETERMINANTS OF HEALTH

Neighborhood.png

Key Terms

01.

Structural Barriers

Structural barriers refer to the physical obstacles and systemic factors that prevent individuals from accessing medical services. These barriers can include inadequate transportation options, inaccessible medical facilities for people with disabilities and geographical remoteness. These obstacles can significantly hinder timely medical care for vulnerable populations, resulting in more urgent medical issues.

02.

Opportunity Atlas

The Opportunity Atlas is an interactive data tool developed by the U.S. Census Bureau in collaboration with Harvard University and Brown University  . It maps the social mobility of individuals based on the neighborhoods where they grew up. By providing granular data on factors such as income, education, and employment, the Atlas allows users to explore how different environments impact life trajectories. In terms of health outcomes, the Opportunity Atlas can highlight disparities in health based on geographic and socioeconomic factors, helping policymakers and researchers identify areas in need of targeted health interventions and resources to improve community well-being.

1

The Invisible Influence: How Your Environment Shapes Your Health

It's no surprise that our physical environment can significantly affect our health and longevity. Environmental factors that can significantly affect our health include air pollution, inadequate water and sanitation, extreme weather conditions and exposure to harmful chemicals.

The World Health Organization estimates that 24% of global deaths are due to the physical environment .

2

The most prevalent health issues arising from poor environmental conditions are noncommunicable diseases such as heart disease, chronic respiratory conditions and various cancers in addition to injuries and respiratory infections. Unsurprisingly, individuals with low incomes residing in areas with higher pollution levels and unsafe drinking water are disproportionately affected. Moreover, structural barriers, such as inadequate transportation or the distance from healthcare facilities, can exacerbate adverse health outcomes by preventing patients from seeking timely intervention for their illnesses.

​

The significant disparity in health outcomes based on physical environment is a global issue that necessitates a coordinated effort from organizations at all levels to redesign infrastructure and support vulnerable populations through systemic changes. In America, the responsibility for addressing widespread issues, like climate change, is often placed on individuals rather than systems (i.e. corporations and the government). For disadvantaged populations living in poor living conditions, we can't place the responsibility of finding healthier living conditions on the individual. We need to support these populations with systemic changes implemented through overarching public policy.

​

This systemic approach is crucial because communities living in poor conditions often also face significant structural barriers, such as inadequate housing, limited access to care, poor sanitation, and environmental hazards, all of which contribute to deteriorating health. Without intervention, residents are left to navigate these challenges alone, exacerbating health disparities and perpetuating cycles of poverty. Implementing systemic changes through public policy can address these root causes by ensuring access to quality healthcare, improving living conditions, and reducing environmental risks. Effective policies can provide the necessary resources and support to uplift vulnerable populations, fostering healthier, more equitable communities. Investing in these changes not only improves individual health outcomes but also enhances the overall well-being and productivity of society. 

 

Hospital organizations can also implement solutions at the local level to address health disparities caused by varied living conditions. We now have data, drilled down to the neighborhood-level, to understand how factors driving social mobility outcomes and differences between areas affect residents' health, even with a mile's distance. 

​

The Opportunity Atlas is a groundbreaking tool developed by Raj Chetty and researchers from Harvard University, Brown University and the U.S. Census Bureau that maps economic opportunities across the United States  . It provides detailed, interactive data on how neighborhood conditions affect future economic success, using markers such as income, employment, and educational attainment. By highlighting variations in outcomes based on where children grow up, the Atlas helps policymakers and community leaders understand and address the root causes of economic inequality, aiming to foster upward mobility. Since we know socioeconomic status affects health, children in high-poverty areas often experience worse health and than those in affluent neighborhoods. Healthcare organizations will have to figure out how to utilize information from their own backyards to design the right solutions based on location conditions and resources.

1

Opportunity Atlas

For example, In the Detroit neighborhood, Boston Edison, black children raised in low-income households grow up to have an average household income of $30,000/year as adults, with less than a 1% incarceration rate. However, in the adjacent Dexter-Linwood neighborhood, the same group earns an average of $22,000/year, with nearly 6% facing incarceration as adults. If some neighborhoods are able to help lift children out of poverty while others trap them in it, the next logical step is to identify the differences between these neighborhoods  .

3

Screenshot 2024-06-07 at 1.52.55 PM.png
Screenshot 2024-06-07 at 1.53.17 PM.png

By leveraging the detailed insights provided by the Opportunity Atlas, hospitals can deliver more equitable and customized healthcare services. Analyzing data on income, education, and employment outcomes helps identify areas with higher social and economic disadvantages, pinpointing communities with greater health risks and unmet needs. Hospitals can then develop targeted outreach programs, allocate resources effectively and collaborate with local organizations to address health disparities. Understanding patients' backgrounds enables organizations to develop personalized care plans and design preventive health strategies. Data from the Opportunity Atlas can also inform training healthcare professionals to ensure they are culturally competent and sensitive to the specific challenges faced by different communities. By leveraging the detailed insights provided by the Opportunity Atlas, hospitals can deliver more equitable, effective, and customized healthcare services that better meet the needs of diverse populations.

​

Banyan Consulting Co is ready to tackle these complex challenges. Our expertise can help hospitals deliver more equitable and customized healthcare services. Reach out today for more information!

Interventions

Collaborative Community Health Initiatives: Hospitals can collaborate with local organizations and policymakers to address the root causes of health disparities. This might involve working on improving housing conditions, increasing access to healthy foods, and enhancing local infrastructure.

 

Targeted Outreach Programs: Hospitals can develop and implement targeted outreach programs in neighborhoods identified as high-risk. This can include mobile health clinics, vaccination drives, and health education initiatives tailored to the specific needs of the community.


Provide Transport: Prominent ride share companies have created healthcare specific ride services (Lyft Healthcare and Uber Health) to serve patients in need of transport. Organizations can collaborate with these types of services and ensure transport is secured for future healthcare appointments and services and removing structural barriers due to transportation. Scheduling rides ahead of time also serves as a commitment device (a tool that helps people adhere to a plan, even when tempted to deviate from it), ensuring patients attend all of their appointments.

​

Personalized Care Plans: Understanding the socioeconomic background of patients can help healthcare providers create more personalized care plans that consider the social determinants of health. This can improve patient compliance and outcomes by addressing other barriers such as financial constraints and patient literacy gaps.

​

Preventive Health Strategies: Hospitals can design preventive health strategies that are specific to the needs of different neighborhoods. For example, areas with higher rates of childhood asthma may benefit from programs focused on reducing environmental triggers and improving air quality.

​

Urban Greenery Programs: On hospital campuses in low-income areas, develop accessible walking areas or community gardens in low-income areas. Research shows that access to green spaces reduces stress and promotes physical activity.

Sources

1. “The Opportunity Atlas.” n.d. Opportunityatlas.org. https://opportunityatlas.org/.

2. World Health Organization. 2023. “Environmental Health Impacts.” Www.who.int. 2023. https://www.who.int/activities/environmental-health-impacts.

3. “Opportunity Atlas: Data Maps the Impact of Where a Child Grows Up.” n.d. Www.rwjf.org. https://www.rwjf.org/en/insights/blog/2019/01/data-maps-the-lifelong-impact-of-where-a-child-grows-up.html.

bottom of page